Who really deserves a knighthood?
14th November 2008
WHEN it comes to knighthoods, Yorkshire, and the business community in particular, never seems to get its fair share.
How many Yorkshire business people can you think of that have knelt before Her Majesty?
This region has been woefully short of knighted entrepreneurs. Of course there is the knight of the aisles Sir Ken Morrison, serial non-executive director Sir Rodney Walker. Sir Graham Hall picked up his gong after his work at the helm of Yorkshire Forward.
But after that I'm struggling to name many more.
I always felt the late Arnold Ziff was deserving of such an honour given his contribution to business, the arts, education, the public sector and so much charitable work.
Another who would carry the honour deservingly well would be former Leeds United chairman, Kalon founder and philanthropist Leslie Silver.
And at the top of my list - and many others - would be Victor Watson.
The former chairman of family firm Waddingtons has just published a fascinating book called The Waddingtons Story which covers its early days as a humble Leeds printer, to its launch of Monopoly in the UK and, perhaps most revealingly, the repelling of two takeover bids from the late media tycoon Robert Maxwell.
Victor has achieved much in business, but this is only part of a life that has certainly been lived in technicolour.
His friend, property entrepreneur Neil Pullan, describes Victor as "a frustrated
actor".
It sums up a man who has done things with panache - the Cary Grant of the printing world.
But as his career as a thespian stretched to amateur dramatics and panto, Victor channelled this performing bent into his other activities.
Oh to have been a spectator when he chaired the Waddingtons board meetings, or hosted shareholders at an AGM.
Then there is his work for the city of Leeds, its charities, chamber of commerce and the arts.
To call him well rounded is an understatement. He's also an accomplished pianist. Public relations man Andrew McKeon tells of a time when he accompanied Victor to the World Monopoly Championships at the Breakers Hotel in Miami with Waddingtons a key sponsor.
Walking past the hotel's vast ballroom one morning, Andrew was drawn to the sound of a Scott Joplin rag being played on its grand piano. There at the keyboard was Victor, relaxing by playing some of his favourite tunes.
At the age of 80 Victor Watson has a CBE where others, who have achieved a lot less, have higher honours.
Perhaps it is because unlike others, he has never gone looking for public glory.
He tells the story of opening a letter from Queen over breakfast one morning which informed him he would receive the CBE.
His wife Sheila said: "What are you going to do about it, you have never had any time for the honours system?"
To which he replied: "That was a rather immature view."
What we need from the powers that be is a mature view of who really deserves the honours.
Have Your Say
I totally agree with the comments about Victor...he is a total star and it is a travesty that he hasn't been for a Knighthood yet...but what about the businesswomen of this region too? Surely there should be a Damehood for Luisa Scachetti of Mamas & Papas in Huddersfield. She has built, from scratch, a well respected world leading brand name over the last 25 years, raised huge amounts for charities and is a wonderfully grounded and pleasant woman to boot! To build such a successful flag ship company in manufacturing and for keeping it all based in Yorkshire I think she would be a good contender too. www.freyasykes.com
Freya Sykes
Hello David This is a great forum to air these views and those who deserve recognition. Qu: Does the RDA have a small sub-committee to ensure appropriate candidates are submitted? I totally agree with the positive comments as regards Victor who has always been an inspiration and given his time to so many younger business people and Junior Chamber members over the years. Leslie has also done so much to put Leeds on the map and those who know John appreciate just how much he has done for Holly Bank. Perhaps I am biased and also in danger of building a ground swell of nominees but C Richard Jackson must be in contention for his contributions not only in several businesses over the years but also for his restless support of charities. Best wishes Martin Allison
Martin Allison
I agree. Victor has been a star contributor and I can think of many knights who are less deserving. Incidentally, some research into whether Yorkshire gets its fair share of honours should be undertaken. Robin Smith
Robin Smith
I agree and what about John Hall formerly of Ring Group now of Volvox Group-he's built two great businesses before you begin talking about his phenomenal contribution to Holly Bank-the home for the seriously disabled including last nights dinner
nick butler
Quite agree We should have Leslie and Victor at the palace together- Superb representatives of Yorkshire business and of personall contribution to our county Nimble thompson
nimble thompson
Victor is the star turn in every way. He never says more than needed and when he does give an opinion it is well considered and wise.
Malcolm Berwin
I absolutely agree - there cannot be many, if indeed any from this region more deserving of this level of recognition - not only for past achievements but also for his lower profile but essential contribution to charities.
David Watt
- Login
- Register Now For Free!
Comment
- Ian Briggs
Happy New Year message from TheBusinessDesk.com - David Parkin
Was that the Cabinet or did I miss them? - David Parkin
David Parkin on the pre-Budget report - David Parkin
Who really deserves a knighthood? - David Parkin
Leeds Bradford is not leisurely - Ian Briggs
Think tank not thinking straight when it comes to Yorkshire - David Parkin
Help? I only arsked. - David Parkin
Would Sir Ken want a Hamster? - David Parkin
How did the YIBC rate this year? - David Parkin
Tragic loss to Yorkshire business




By David Parkin
Editor